Marisa Stephens is the Director of Marketing at Southern First Bank, headquartered in Greenville, South Carolina, with eight markets across the Carolinas and Georgia. She’s been in the role for about five and a half years, but her career in digital marketing and social media goes back 13 years, and very little of it was spent in banking.
On this episode of Bound by Banking, Marisa talks about why she’s proud to be an “outsider” in the industry, what actually works on a bank’s social channels, how a Hot Ones–style United Way fundraiser turned into the talk of Greenville, and where she thinks banks overcomplicate and oversimplify their marketing.
Coming From Outside Banking Is an Advantage
Before Southern First, Marisa worked at an advertising agency on the automotive side, where the clients were spending close to $750,000 a month. She started on the social team, then moved into SEM and digital advertising, where she sharpened her technical skills and learned to talk analytics and ROI with clients who needed to see results.
From there she moved into real estate, marketing the brand while acting as an in-house agency for around 200 agents. Real estate is fast-paced and high-stress, and realtors take their marketing personally because their face is on everything. That’s where she “built her people skills and a thicker skin” as she put it.
She expected banking to be a whole new language of interest rates and basis points. Instead she found it wasn’t that different. Buying a car, buying a home and choosing where to put your money are three of the biggest financial decisions people make, and in all three you want an expert guiding you. Marisa put it best. “It always comes down to people and relationships.”
That’s why she still sees herself as an outsider, and wants to stay that way. “We don’t wanna look and sound like every other bank,” she said. It also makes her the person who can say, “Clients don’t know what this means,” when the acronyms start flying.
Nobody Opens Social Media to Compare CD Rates
Southern First’s social presence has grown fast. Ryan’s research before the episode found roughly 580% growth in organic engagement. When he asked whether the change came from format, strategy, the people on camera or just posting consistently, Marisa’s answer was “Option E”: the right combination of all of it.
The common thread among it all is to focus on real people though. Marketers can get lost in metrics and in whatever the algorithm seems to reward this week. Marisa’s advice is to zoom out and remember why people are on social in the first place: “to keep up with family and friends, to be entertained, to catch the news or share a relatable meme.” As she put it, “they’re not going on there to find out which bank has the best CD rate.”
Her own data backs this up. Posts about product features, interest rates and fraud don’t get engagement. That doesn’t mean the bank stops talking about those things, because they still matter. But more of the thought that social might not be the right channel for them. She treats every post as an experiment and lets the results tell her what people actually want to see.
Your Best Content Is Already Happening Inside Your Four Walls
A lot of Marisa’s job, she says, is just looking around. “There are great stories happening inside the bank every day, and the work is figuring out how to tell them.”
Her favorite example: every month, Southern First holds a company-wide staff meeting for all 300-plus employees, and it opens with five minutes of “Dog of the Month.” Sometimes it’s a team member’s dog, sometimes it’s a dog from the Humane Society that’s up for adoption. The tradition was around long before Marisa arrived, and her first reaction was, “Why does nobody know about this?” To her it said a lot about the culture: in an important company meeting, everyone takes five minutes to just have fun together.
Now Dog of the Month goes on social every month, and clients look forward to it. People tell her they can’t wait to see who’s next.
Marisa likes having a few recurring anchors on the calendar, like Dog of the Month and quarterly financial results, while leaving room between them for the stories that pop up: something that happened downstairs, or a client who came into the Charlotte office with a great story about how the bank helped them. Many customers only ever see the teller line or the app, so a glimpse behind the scenes goes a long way.
Memorable Beats Measurable
Southern First has partnered with United Way for a long time, and its annual employee giving campaign ties directly to the bank’s mission of impacting lives in the communities it serves. Over the years it grew from a fundraising drive into a cultural moment for the team, and then into a marketing moment too.
The year it won United Way’s Most Creative Campaign award, the bank did Hot Ones, the YouTube show where celebrities answer tough questions while eating progressively hotter wings. Marisa was watching it at home and thought, “What if we did this?” She convinced the bank’s president and CEO to do it with her in front of the whole company, and they raised a lot of money.
Then it took on a life of its own. United Way asked her to write a playbook, and eight to ten other Greenville companies ran their own Hot Ones campaigns that year. Years later, people still call her “the Hot Ones lady” at networking events. This year the bank brought it back as a March Madness–style bracket, and Marisa took the hot seat again, this time with the CFO.
So how do you defend that kind of work to a board that cares about ROI? Marisa has strong support from her board and executive team, and she says that when something becomes the talk of the town, you don’t really have to explain it. The value of doing something authentic, memorable and relatable becomes obvious, even if you’re not tracking the ROI.
It worked because the concept was familiar, it was surprising coming from a bank, the team was willing to laugh at itself, and it still tied back to the mission.
Banks Overcomplicate the Data and Oversimplify the Brand
For the last question, Ryan asked where banks overcomplicate marketing and where they oversimplify it. Marisa kept it short.
Banks overcomplicate marketing by getting too far into the weeds on data and leaning too heavily on AI right out of the gate, and forgetting that marketing is about being real, authentic and human.
They oversimplify it by thinking of marketing as flyers and campaigns, and forgetting that two of their most powerful marketing tools are their brand and their client experience. “If you don’t have those 2 things down, the rest doesn’t really matter.”
Ryan, (a self-described data nerd) admitted he’s been guilty of following the numbers too far. Marisa’s fix is simple: get up from your desk. Walk around and talk to the people on the front lines about what clients are coming in with this week and what questions they’re asking. The data is helpful, but so is the team. She also schedules time to work outside the office, at a coffee shop or over lunch with someone in a different industry, because a fresh perspective helps you see what you miss when you’re heads-down all day.
Watch the Full Conversation
Marisa’s big idea is that people connect with people, not products. Post the real stories already happening at your bank, leave room in the calendar for the unexpected, and don’t be afraid to do something that gets your town talking. Get the brand and client experience right, and the rest of your marketing gets a lot easier.
Watch the full episode of Bound by Banking with Marisa Stephens here: